There wasn't a single female dog in the villain's huge pack.
Message posted on 2009-09-03 01:09:18
KB said:
Kevin (note: a female bird) "talks" to her babies... some of whom presumably might be female. WEAK.
Message posted on 2010-06-18 23:58:28
Olivia Short said:
In a film that has so few characters I think it is harsh it critize it for not having two females talking to each other. I can't see where they could have added more characters into the film without spoiling it, it stands as an excellent film as it is. Some times the Bechdel test just isn't practical.
Message posted on 2010-07-02 10:46:06
Laura Ruth said:
At the end of the movie it was blatantly apparent to me that it didn't pass the test, and this bothered me. I do think the test is necessary, especially in kid's movies. At the end, the mother watches as her son gets his award and just sits in the audience while she lets a stranger act as the father figure. Why can't she? Why is she a bystander? She doesn't even speak. It's like saying that moms just cheer you on but they can't REALLY support you. Not okay in my book.
Message posted on 2010-07-19 10:25:34
Fatpie42 said:
Thinking about how this fails, it amused me to think that the only female character is a bird named "Kevin". Lol!
Message posted on 2010-08-22 10:51:35
Elisa said:
@Laura Ruth
If I remember the movie correctly, the boy's mother is actually dead. What we see in the end of the movie is just the boy's imagination as he wishes his mother was there.
Message posted on 2011-02-16 21:40:39
Victor said:
I have to disagree with Olivia. The movie has plenty of male characters talking to one another about something other than women, so I don't see why it wouldn't have had room for the reverse.
Message posted on 2011-07-07 22:52:42
Angel said:
Elisa, it's his stepmother, who does have a name (although I can't recall it)
Message posted on 2011-10-11 12:10:52
Gen said:
If all the genders in the movie had been reversed, I guarantee you that there would be people disagreeing with the rating of the movie purely because the entire trip would have been because of a 'man'--if you'll recall, the whole thing was an attempt by Carl to finally live Ellie's dream.
Now, I won't argue at all that it doesn't pass the test--it clearly doesn't--but I have seen comments on other movies claiming they don't pass because everything in the movie was because of a man. Well, everything that takes place in the movie 'Up' is because of a woman, and it was an incredibly touching tale, so I don't think that just because it fails the Bechdel test means it's anti-feminist in the slightest.
Also, I do believe Elisa is right, Russel was just imagining his mother being there, and being proud of him.
Message posted on 2011-10-12 00:19:07
Victoria said:
His mother was definitely alive and at the ceremony.
His parents are divorced, and his dad remarried (or is living with) someone named Phyllis. Which is why he sees him less. When Karl says you call your mother by her name he says Phyllis isn't my mom.
But he talk's about his mom also when Karl suggest playing let's see who can be quiet the longest he say's my mom loves that game.